Peer Review Checklist: What Reviewers Actually Check Before Accepting Your Paper
Most rejection letters don't explain what actually went wrong — "insufficient novelty" or "methodological concerns" tells you a reviewer wasn't convinced, not which specific thing to fix. This is the checklist version of what a reviewer is actually weighing when they read your submission.
1. Novelty
Is this genuinely new, or a small variation on existing work? Reviewers are asking: what does this paper contribute that the field didn't already have? A result can be solid and still get rejected if it reads as incremental without the paper explicitly making the case for why the increment matters.
Check: does your introduction state, explicitly, what's new here — not just what you did?
2. Methodology
Is the approach sound, and is it described in enough detail that someone else could run it? Reviewers look for whether the method actually tests what the paper claims, whether comparisons are fair, and whether limitations are acknowledged rather than hidden.
Check: could a reader reproduce your method from the paper alone, without emailing you?
3. Results
Do the results support the claims being made, or do they overreach? A common reviewer complaint is a results section that reports numbers accurately but a discussion section that claims more than the numbers show.
Check: read your abstract's claims next to your results table — does every claim have a number behind it?
4. Baselines
Were the right comparisons made? A result that beats a weak or outdated baseline isn't convincing — reviewers check whether you compared against the strongest relevant prior work, not just whatever was easiest to re-implement.
Check: is there a baseline in your related work that you didn't actually compare against, and if so, why not?
5. Data collection
Where did the data come from, and is the collection process described well enough to trust it? This covers sample size, selection criteria, potential bias, and whether the data actually supports the scope of claims being made.
Check: if a skeptical reviewer asked "how do you know this sample isn't biased," do you have an answer in the paper already?
Using this before you submit
Reading your own paper against this list catches some things — but it's hard to be the adversarial reader your paper actually needs when you already know what you meant to say. Submission Copilot runs a structured pre-submission review across exactly these five categories, scoring each one the way a reviewer would, so you see the gaps before a program committee does. Try it free.